Skip to content

Easy and Cheap

July 2, 2012

Reflecting on the recent debate over mandatory helmet laws, blogger Elly Blue has this to say:

One thing that is certain is that all-ages mandatory helmet laws do more harm than good, reducing the amount of cycling and therefore its safety in any given place. [Bicycle advocate Koula] Redmond compared helmets with sharrows—an easy, cheap, way for advocates and politicians to act, even if the effect is more symbolic than useful or safe.

I think that’s being too polite, as if mandatory helmet laws and street markings such as sharrows are merely the result of sincere but misguided advocates and pro-bicycle politicians too timid to call for protected infrastructure.  In the case of sharrows, a determined group of Brooklynites vowed to continue fighting for full protection after settling for sharrows as a compromise with avid motorists on the community board.  And when it comes to mandatory helmet laws, no advocate or politician would seriously support them from a best-we-can-get-for-now point of view.

On the contrary, almost all of the pro-helmet-law rhetoric here in New York has come two men: David Greenfield, who never met a piece of pavement he didn’t want to turn into a parking space, and John Liu, a politician with zero prior history with pro-bicycle policies.  Neither of them proposed a helmet law because it’s the “easy, cheap way” to protect cyclists.  They did it because it’s an “easy, cheap way” to keep those darn bicycles off of city streets.

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: